Supreme Court Round Up 2023-2024

The United States Supreme Court’s 2023-2024 term proved to be monumental. The Court issued several decisions that will have a long-lasting impact on the practice of employment law and on the power of federal administrative agencies. In today’s blog post, we will take a look at four key rulings from the 2023-2024 term.

Court discards the Chevron doctrine

In Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, the Court significantly weakened the power of federal agencies by overturning Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc. Under Chevron, courts were required to defer to administrative agencies’ interpretations of the statutes in that they were responsible for overseeing, when statutory ambiguities existed.


In Loper, the Court ruled that the judiciary is responsible for resolving statutory ambiguities and that deferring to an agency’s interpretation was prohibited by the Administrative Procedures Act (APA). As such, the Court determined that the Chevron doctrine was inappropriate under the APA. In the wake of this decision, courts have far greater latitude to strike down agency rules. In addition, an employer will likely have a greater chance of success in challenging an agency’s interpretation. However, determining whether an agency’s interpretation is binding and controlling for a particular employer may prove to be more difficult, as those interpretations will likely face far greater legal scrutiny. As such, employers will need to closely monitor any legal challenges to the regulations that govern their industry and pay particular attention to how specific Circuit Courts view the regulations at issue.


Employers given more time to challenge federal regulations

In Corner Post Inc. v. Board of Governors, the Court issued a decision allowing employers to challenge federal regulations, even after they are finalized. In Comer, the Court ruled that a six-year statute of limitations under the APA starts after someone is actually injured by the regulation. This ultimately stretches the timeframe employers have to file suit and challenge a regulation. Therefore, should a federal agency issue a decision that impacts a particular employer, that employer can challenge the validity of the regulation even though it’s final. This gives employers a powerful tool to challenge an agency’s regulatory authority.


Court weakens NLRB’s authority to impose financial penalties on employers

The Supreme Court sided with Starbucks over the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) in Starbucks Corp. v. McKinney. The case revolved around Starbucks’ decision to fire some employees hosting media interviews after hours. The fired workers then filed an unfair labor practices claim with the NLRB.


The NLRB convinced a lower court to reinstate employees who had been fired while the legal battle ensued. Under Section 10(j) of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), the NLRB may ask a federal district judge to order certain temporary measures, like reinstating fired employees while an unfair labor practice claim is litigated. In Starbucks Corp., the NLRB convinced the lower court to use a stringent standard to evaluate the board’s request.


When the case was brought to the Supreme Court, it stated that courts must use a traditional and more stringent test to review requests to reinstate employees during a legal battle. Therefore, the Court’s decision makes it more difficult for the NLRB to obtain relief for employees who have brought unfair practices claims before the Board. However, even though the Court’s decision was a win for employers, companies should still review their workplace policies and procedures to ensure that they are complying with the NLRA.


The Court rejects retaliatory intent for retaliation claims under Sarbanes-Oxley

In Murray v. UBS Securities, the Supreme Court unanimously held that a whistleblower does not need to establish that an employer acted with retaliatory intent to prove a retaliation claim under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX). Under SOX, employees of publicly traded companies are protected from reporting financial wrongdoing. As such, covered businesses cannot fire, demote, suspend, or engage in other similar discriminatory conduct against employees when they engage in protected activity under the SOX.


A circuit split had emerged regarding the level of proof plaintiffs need to establish to prove retaliation under SOX. Specifically, the Court found that the whistleblower only needed to prove that the protected activity was a contributing factor in the employer’s adverse employment decision. The Court also noted that an employee does not need to prove that the employer acted with discriminatory intent to establish his or her whistleblower claim.


Now that the Court has made it easier for whistleblowers to file claims under SOX, employers must take steps to establish that any adverse action was taken for non-discriminatory purposes. The decision stresses the importance of maintaining documentation of the reasons for an employment decision. Also, an employer should consult with counsel before making an adverse employee action against an employee who has engaged in protected activity.

Recent Posts

Main street in Lexington, KY
By Lockaby PLLC • November 6, 2026
The process of selling a business can be overwhelming. Understanding the process can be helpful for business owners looking for an M&A attorney for their transaction
Abby Wearden, title Commonly Overlooked Kentucky Wage and Hour Rules
By Lockaby PLLC • November 3, 2026
Commonly overlooked wage and hour rules in Kentucky, like payroll mistakes, can compound into bigger problems when they affect multiple employees over time.
One half with a typewriter, rotary phone and notebook. The other half laptop, phone, and tablet
By Lockaby PLLC • October 28, 2026
Dolly Parton's 9 to 5 was released over 40 years ago, but it is a great reminder for modern employers about what can happen when workplace problem goes unaddressed.
Abby Wearden in front of building with text religious accommodations and artificial intelligence
By Lockaby PLLC • October 27, 2026
Are employees able to ask for religious accommodations from using artificial intelligence at work? Our YouTube video discusses this and employer obligations
Picture of a red traffic light with a brick building and blue sky in the background.
By Lockaby PLLC • October 22, 2026
Butterball agreed. to pay $230,000 in an ADA settlement with the EEOC. What can employers learn from this case? Read our blog to find out! Questions? Contact us!
Abigail Wearden in front of a building, Title: What is a Performance Improvement Plan?
By Lockaby PLLC • October 12, 2026
Performance improvement plans can help employers address performance problems. What should employers consider before introducing a PIP?
Horse statue with fountain in the background
By Lockaby PLLC • October 2, 2026
Payroll errors don't have to be intentional to create significant liability. What can employers learn from DoorDash's recent settlement with New York City?
Street with trees and brick buildings
By Lockaby PLLC • September 25, 2026
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals shifts the focus in religious accommodations cases from process to motive. Read our blog to learn more!
Man with glasses speaking, text in background
By Lockaby PLLC • September 23, 2026
A purchase agreement turns the framework of an M&A transaction into a binding contract between the parties. Watch this video to learn the ins and outs!
Brick exterior of a house with decorative rails around a porch
By Lockaby PLLC • September 18, 2026
Have you ever wondered how M&A financing works? Read our latest blog to understand the difference between cash, debt, and equity financing in M&A transactions.
Show More