BNSF Disability Lawsuit Highlights the Importance of Evaluating Accommodation Requests
In October 2026, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) sued BNSF Railway, alleging the company fired an employee after denying his request for a disability-related accommodation.
The lawsuit highlights the importance of evaluating accommodation requests and working with the employee to identify a reasonable accommodation.
What Happened?
According to the EEOC, BNSF hired an employee with Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, a genetic condition that can cause joint pain, in April 2023. During required field training, the employee experienced hand pain while using a large spike maul. He requested permission to use a smaller-handled spike maul that a supervisor was already using.
The EEOC alleges that BNSF denied the request, failed to offer an alternative accommodation, and subsequently terminated the employee.
The agency filed a federal lawsuit alleging disability discrimination and retaliation under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). The EEOC is seeking monetary damages and other relief. The allegations have not been established in court.
What Should Employers Know?
Accommodation Requests Require Individual Consideration
Under the ADA, covered employers generally must provide reasonable accommodations to qualified employees with disabilities, unless doing so imposes an undue hardship.
When an employee requests an accommodation, employers should evaluate the employee's limitations, the essential functions of the position, and potential accommodations that would allow the employee to perform those functions.
The employee's request involved equipment already in use at BNSF. While employers aren't required to provide every accommodation an employee requests, they should evaluate available options before deciding an request cannot be met.
Explore Available Options for Accommodations
An employee's requested accommodation isn't necessarily the only accommodation an employer must consider. If a particular modification is ineffective or would create an undue hardship, employers may need to explore other options.
This is an interactive process that allows employers and employees to identify potential accommodations based on the employee's needs and the requirements of the job. Employers should also be mindful of the ADA's protections against discrimination and retaliation when making employment decisions involving employees who have requested accommodations.
The Key Takeaway
The BNSF lawsuit serves as a reminder that accommodation requests deserve individualized consideration, even when they involve seemingly minor workplace modifications.
Before denying a request or taking related employment action, employers should evaluate available accommodations, consider whether an effective alternative exists, and document the process.
Lockaby PLLC advises employers on disability accommodation requests, ADA compliance, and other employment law matters. Consulting counsel early can help businesses evaluate their obligations and determine an appropriate response.







