Can a Job Transfer Be a Discriminatory Action? Supreme Court Considers New Title VII Case

In employment discrimination cases, employees must prove that they suffered an “adverse employment action.” For years, the courts did not consider an employer’s transfer of an employee to another position, to another shift, an “adverse employment action.” However, the Supreme Court of the United States is considering changing this long-standing standard of interpretation and could expand the scope of discrimination cases.

On December 6, 2023, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Muldrow v. City of St. Louis. The plaintiff was a sergeant with the St. Louis Police Department who worked in the intelligence division, investigating public corruption and human trafficking cases. The plaintiff’s position with the intelligence division gave her the ability to earn up to $17,500 in overtime pay because she worked on an FBI task force. The position afforded the plaintiff various other benefits, such as generally working a nine-to-five schedule and the ability to wear plain clothes. Eventually, the plaintiff was involuntarily transferred to the city’s Fifth District, where she supervised police officers on patrol, reviewed and approved arrests, and worked on crimes such as homicides, robberies, and assaults.  In this latter position, the plaintiff was ineligible for overtime and was forced to wear a uniform.


After the city denied her request to transfer from the Fifth District, the plaintiff sued the city, alleging gender discrimination and retaliation. She alleged that the city discriminated against her by involuntarily transferring her from her position in the intelligence division, claiming that her supervisor wanted a man in the position.


Both the federal district court and the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit ruled in favor of the city and dismissed her suit. Both courts reasoned that the plaintiff failed to prove that her transfer amounted to an “adverse employment action” that caused material harm.


Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1996 prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex. To prevail under Title VII, plaintiffs alleging discrimination must establish they suffered an adverse employment action. Traditional examples of an adverse employment action include being fired, suspended, demoted, or receiving less pay or benefits. In addition, many federal circuits require plaintiffs to establish that the alleged discriminatory conduct subjected them to a “significant disadvantage” in order to prevail.


In Muldrow, the court of appeals found that the plaintiff failed to establish a significant injury or harm. "To be materially adverse, retaliation cannot be trivial. It must produce some injury or harm," the court noted. Simply being denied a transfer would not rise to this requirement.


The Supreme Court granted the plaintiff’s petition for certiorari. The Supreme Court is not determining whether the plaintiff was discriminated against due to her sex; rather, the Court is set to determine whether an involuntary transfer alone constitutes an adverse employment action under Title VII. Should the Court rule in favor of the plaintiff, this would significantly increase the number of cases that plaintiffs could bring against employers under Title VII, as it would negate the “significant disadvantage” requirement and otherwise upend years of case law on what constitutes an adverse employment action.


Regardless of the outcome, employers should diligently document their decision-making process with respect to transfers and other major employment decisions. Doing so will assist employers in defending against claims premised upon a transfer. This will become especially important if the Court removes the “significant disadvantage” requirement that many courts have recognized for Title VII claims.


Do you have questions about how to establish best practices with respect to documenting employment decisions, such as transfers? Is your business being accused of discriminatory conduct? Do you need insight to ensure your business is protected from legal exposure related to transfers or other significant employment decisions? Let’s connect.

Recent Posts

Main street in Lexington, KY
By Lockaby PLLC • November 6, 2026
The process of selling a business can be overwhelming. Understanding the process can be helpful for business owners looking for an M&A attorney for their transaction
Abby Wearden, title Commonly Overlooked Kentucky Wage and Hour Rules
By Lockaby PLLC • November 3, 2026
Commonly overlooked wage and hour rules in Kentucky, like payroll mistakes, can compound into bigger problems when they affect multiple employees over time.
One half with a typewriter, rotary phone and notebook. The other half laptop, phone, and tablet
By Lockaby PLLC • October 28, 2026
Dolly Parton's 9 to 5 was released over 40 years ago, but it is a great reminder for modern employers about what can happen when workplace problem goes unaddressed.
Abby Wearden in front of building with text religious accommodations and artificial intelligence
By Lockaby PLLC • October 27, 2026
Are employees able to ask for religious accommodations from using artificial intelligence at work? Our YouTube video discusses this and employer obligations
Picture of a red traffic light with a brick building and blue sky in the background.
By Lockaby PLLC • October 22, 2026
Butterball agreed. to pay $230,000 in an ADA settlement with the EEOC. What can employers learn from this case? Read our blog to find out! Questions? Contact us!
Abigail Wearden in front of a building, Title: What is a Performance Improvement Plan?
By Lockaby PLLC • October 12, 2026
Performance improvement plans can help employers address performance problems. What should employers consider before introducing a PIP?
Horse statue with fountain in the background
By Lockaby PLLC • October 2, 2026
Payroll errors don't have to be intentional to create significant liability. What can employers learn from DoorDash's recent settlement with New York City?
Street with trees and brick buildings
By Lockaby PLLC • September 25, 2026
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals shifts the focus in religious accommodations cases from process to motive. Read our blog to learn more!
Man with glasses speaking, text in background
By Lockaby PLLC • September 23, 2026
A purchase agreement turns the framework of an M&A transaction into a binding contract between the parties. Watch this video to learn the ins and outs!
Brick exterior of a house with decorative rails around a porch
By Lockaby PLLC • September 18, 2026
Have you ever wondered how M&A financing works? Read our latest blog to understand the difference between cash, debt, and equity financing in M&A transactions.
Show More