Second Circuit Clarifies ADA: Reasonable Accommodations Include Well-Being

On March 25, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals’ ruling in Tudor v. Whitehall Central School District established that employees with disabilities may be entitled to reasonable accommodations, even if they can complete their jobs without them.

Tudor v. Whitehall Central School District 

Angel Tudor, a high school teacher in New York, diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), requested brief afternoon breaks as a reasonable accommodation to help manage her condition. However, the school district denied her request, so she filed a lawsuit under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) for failure to accommodate. Since Tudor admitted she could still perform the functions of her job, although under significant stress and harm, the lower court dismissed her claim. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals reversed its decision. The court emphasized that the ADA mandates reasonable accommodations not only to enable job performance but also to promote employee well-being and inclusion in the workplace.


Breaking Down the Second Circuit’s Ruling


The ADA’s Definition Matters

The ADA says a “qualified employee” is someone who can do the main parts of their job, with or without help. The Second Circuit explained that this means employers still need to consider giving accommodations, even if the employee can technically do the job without them. Employers should review and update their ADA policies to ensure that they align with the current legal standards.


Accommodation is About Inclusion, Not Just Enablement

In the past, accommodations were seen as helping disabled employees meet basic job requirements. However, the Second Circuit's opinion shifts the focus to ensuring fair working conditions, addressing issues like stress, emotional safety, or worsened medical symptoms, even if job performance is not directly affected.


Since managers and supervisors often receive accommodation requests first, provide them with training on ADA obligations and effective, empathetic communication. For mid-size to large organizations, a cross-functional team, including HR, legal, facilities, and occupational health representatives, can evaluate complex accommodation requests.


Undue Hardship is the Only Exception

Employers do not have to grant every accommodation request, but they must show a clear "undue hardship,” meaning it would be difficult or expensive to accommodate, considering their size, resources, and operations. This creates a high standard for denying accommodations and places the burden of proof on the employer. Employers should track all accommodation requests, resolutions, and follow-ups to ensure consistency, fairness, and legal defensibility.


The Second Circuit’s ruling is consistent with decisions from other circuit courts, reinforcing the principle that employers must evaluate reasonable accommodation requests even when an employee is technically able to perform their job without them. The Tudor decision confirms that the ADA’s protections do extend to accommodations that improve the overall workplace environment.

Recent Posts

Main street in Lexington, KY
By Lockaby PLLC • November 6, 2026
The process of selling a business can be overwhelming. Understanding the process can be helpful for business owners looking for an M&A attorney for their transaction
Abby Wearden, title Commonly Overlooked Kentucky Wage and Hour Rules
By Lockaby PLLC • November 3, 2026
Commonly overlooked wage and hour rules in Kentucky, like payroll mistakes, can compound into bigger problems when they affect multiple employees over time.
One half with a typewriter, rotary phone and notebook. The other half laptop, phone, and tablet
By Lockaby PLLC • October 28, 2026
Dolly Parton's 9 to 5 was released over 40 years ago, but it is a great reminder for modern employers about what can happen when workplace problem goes unaddressed.
Abby Wearden in front of building with text religious accommodations and artificial intelligence
By Lockaby PLLC • October 27, 2026
Are employees able to ask for religious accommodations from using artificial intelligence at work? Our YouTube video discusses this and employer obligations
Picture of a red traffic light with a brick building and blue sky in the background.
By Lockaby PLLC • October 22, 2026
Butterball agreed. to pay $230,000 in an ADA settlement with the EEOC. What can employers learn from this case? Read our blog to find out! Questions? Contact us!
Abigail Wearden in front of a building, Title: What is a Performance Improvement Plan?
By Lockaby PLLC • October 12, 2026
Performance improvement plans can help employers address performance problems. What should employers consider before introducing a PIP?
Horse statue with fountain in the background
By Lockaby PLLC • October 2, 2026
Payroll errors don't have to be intentional to create significant liability. What can employers learn from DoorDash's recent settlement with New York City?
Street with trees and brick buildings
By Lockaby PLLC • September 25, 2026
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals shifts the focus in religious accommodations cases from process to motive. Read our blog to learn more!
Man with glasses speaking, text in background
By Lockaby PLLC • September 23, 2026
A purchase agreement turns the framework of an M&A transaction into a binding contract between the parties. Watch this video to learn the ins and outs!
Brick exterior of a house with decorative rails around a porch
By Lockaby PLLC • September 18, 2026
Have you ever wondered how M&A financing works? Read our latest blog to understand the difference between cash, debt, and equity financing in M&A transactions.
Show More