Can Prior Salary Levels Reflect Underlying Sex Discrimination?

The federal Equal Pay Act (EPA or Act) mandates that employers provide “equal pay for equal work regardless of sex.” The Act has four exceptions, one of which allows unequal pay when the employer bases the disparity on the nonspecific, broad standard of “any other factor other than sex.”

What if prior salary is based on gender?

A hot issue nationally is whether setting a new unequal salary level between the sexes on the new hire’s historical salary level is legitimate because it is “any other factor other than sex.” While it literally is another factor – prior salary – the concern is that if women’s salaries continue to be based on their previous salaries, a historical pay disparity based on discrimination – either for an individual or because of a pattern or practice of lower salaries or wages for female employees as a group – will be perpetuated if future pay is lower than that received by males doing the same work because it is based on past discriminatory pay patterns.

In other words, while it is literally a factor other than sex, in practice, past salary is just a stand-in for a factor that is based on sex.


Salary history disclosure bans

This is enough of a concern that some state and local governments across the country have made inquiries about past salary in a legislative attempt to narrow the pay gap between the genders. For example, most Louisville/Jefferson County Metro Government agencies or departments may not ask job applicants about their salary histories (but there is no statewide Kentucky ban as of this writing).


Federal courts disagree

However, the federal circuit courts are split on the question under the Equal Pay Act, and a California school district employer has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to decide the issue, in which case the decision would apply nationally to Equal Pay Act cases (and likely to unequal pay cases under Title VII’s mandate against sex discrimination).


The Rizo case

In Fresno County Superintendent of Schools v. Rizo, the district hired plaintiff Rizo as a math consultant, for which her starting salary was set 5% higher than her previous salary. The district, in its Supreme Court petition for certiorari, explained that the district considered this practice neutral and objective, and guaranteed a raise to all new workers.


When Rizo learned three years later that she was making less than her male colleagues, she sued the district. Eventually, the suit ended up before the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, which held that an employer could never use prior salary to set a new salary under the Act. The defendant school district employer then filed the current petition with the highest court.


Three other circuits say that past salary may always be considered, and four others allow consideration sometimes. For example, the 6th Circuit, which includes Kentucky, says that past salary may only be used to set unequal salary levels if there is a “legitimate business reason.”


The Supreme Court may well decide to grant the petition and take on this important issue. This would provide guidance to employers in developing policy and procedure in setting pay levels that would comply with federal law.


Recent Posts

Buildings in downtown Lexington, KY -- Fifth Third Blue Building
By Lockaby PLLC • November 20, 2026
What can employers learn from a recent EEOC lawsuit concerning BNSF Railway and its alleged failure to accommodate an employee with a protected disability.
Main street in Lexington, KY
By Lockaby PLLC • November 6, 2026
The process of selling a business can be overwhelming. Understanding the process can be helpful for business owners looking for an M&A attorney for their transaction
Abby Wearden, title Commonly Overlooked Kentucky Wage and Hour Rules
By Lockaby PLLC • November 3, 2026
Commonly overlooked wage and hour rules in Kentucky, like payroll mistakes, can compound into bigger problems when they affect multiple employees over time.
One half with a typewriter, rotary phone and notebook. The other half laptop, phone, and tablet
By Lockaby PLLC • October 28, 2026
Dolly Parton's 9 to 5 was released over 40 years ago, but it is a great reminder for modern employers about what can happen when workplace problem goes unaddressed.
Abby Wearden in front of building with text religious accommodations and artificial intelligence
By Lockaby PLLC • October 27, 2026
Are employees able to ask for religious accommodations from using artificial intelligence at work? Our YouTube video discusses this and employer obligations
Picture of a red traffic light with a brick building and blue sky in the background.
By Lockaby PLLC • October 22, 2026
Butterball agreed. to pay $230,000 in an ADA settlement with the EEOC. What can employers learn from this case? Read our blog to find out! Questions? Contact us!
Abigail Wearden in front of a building, Title: What is a Performance Improvement Plan?
By Lockaby PLLC • October 12, 2026
Performance improvement plans can help employers address performance problems. What should employers consider before introducing a PIP?
Horse statue with fountain in the background
By Lockaby PLLC • October 2, 2026
Payroll errors don't have to be intentional to create significant liability. What can employers learn from DoorDash's recent settlement with New York City?
Street with trees and brick buildings
By Lockaby PLLC • September 25, 2026
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals shifts the focus in religious accommodations cases from process to motive. Read our blog to learn more!
Man with glasses speaking, text in background
By Lockaby PLLC • September 23, 2026
A purchase agreement turns the framework of an M&A transaction into a binding contract between the parties. Watch this video to learn the ins and outs!
Show More